Hanging Myself Wirelessly

Around midnight, while typing ping -t 192.168.1.11 with one hand while the other held a tiny flathead screwdriver point across two Flash ROM pins, I thought to myself "Self, what the hell do you think you’re doing?"

I’ve been listening to Steve Gibson’s podcast called Security Now! since it began a few months ago. It is a great podcast for everyone who wants to learn about how to keep both home and corporate computers safe from threats. They’ve had a great series on wireless (WiFi) security that boils down to this: if you’re not using WPA (or derivative, such as Radius), you’re simply not secure. Disabling SSID broadcast and MAC filtering don’t help squat. Anyone using KisMAC or NetStumbler can be on your WEP "protected" in less than an hour just by listening (or, sniffing, if you like that term better).

So all this has had me very worried since our network is far less secure than I thought it was. We’ve been hacked once, although I’m pretty sure it was a neighbor just trying out NetStumbler for fun. I didn’t want anyone getting on our network and using our broadband for free or worse, getting onto our systems and snooping. I don’t need somebody getting my old tax files or anything1 Why did we have a WEP network in the first place, you ask? TiVo can’t use WPA encryption methods. Okay, the solution there is to use a USB ethernet adapter (as opposed to the USB WiFi adapter we have now) and then bridge it onto the wireless network with something that can use WPA. Simple enough, right? No, not really.

First of all, TiVo has very limited drivers for network adapters. I finally went with the Netgear FA120, and it works great. For the wireless bridge, I first thought I’d use a wireless access point by Linksys. I’ve had great luck with their routers and other network gear, this seemed promising. Well no amount of tinkering seemed to get the access point to act in repeater mode (think of a wireless bridge that also acts as a signal booster), despite all the firmware upgrades that claimed to fix that exact same problem.

Sveasoft Firmware

I successfully installed the Sveasoft firmware on my older router.

Next, I tried to use two of the same wireless routers with third party software by Sveasoft which allows the second router to act as a repeater and access point. This seemed ideal since routers are cheaper than access points and have rebates to help the cost even more. I was able to upgrade the firmware on my old router without problem, but sadly things didn’t go so well for the new router (both have to have the third party firmware).

Router Guts

You ever wonder what you’re router looked like on the inside? Hard to believe that’s a 125Mhz Linux computer, huh?

The firmware upgrade froze up and the power light just started flashing. If you own a Linksys WRT54G, let me tell you that the blinking power LED is sort of like seeing a human bleeding from the ears: a small sign that something terrible has happened. I tried hard resets as well as trying flashing the router with older Linksys firmware. I even tried a warranty voiding, last ditch effort to get it into failsafe mode. Around midnight, while typing ping -t 192.168.1.11 with one hand while the other held a tiny flathead screwdriver point across two Flash ROM pins, I thought to myself "Self, what the hell do you think you’re doing?" I fancy myself as power user, but this was way above and beyond what I should be attempting for a piece of hardware I could simply return as being defective.

The next day, I returned the "bricked" WRT54G to CompUSA and tried to look for a replacement. The problem is, they didn’t have any of the older, Linux OS versions; they only had the new V5.0 models, which can’t use any of the fancy third party firmware. Same thing at OfficeMax, Circuit City, and Best Buy: only the new, improved easy setup models. Finally, at Best Buy (as I was about to drive over to check Staples), I though that maybe I was going about this all wrong. Wouldn’t power-line adapters do the same trick, and negate the need for dumbing-down my wireless network just for TiVo? So that’s where I stand now. I may still have issues with the older wiring in our home, but could it be worse than finding every way conceivable to break our wireless network? I hope not.

  1. My ideal solution is to eventually have a network storage that will only allow machines I assign to it access, and then via password. This way I can even just remove it from the network, or isolate it, all together. []

5 thoughts on “Hanging Myself Wirelessly”

  1. …oh come on, man! Just one more hit. All I need is just 30 more minutes. That’ll keep me going. I swear I won’t need any more after that. Honest.

    Actually, the one nice thing about TiVo, is the fact that the television we do watch is actually stuff we want to watch. No more just surfing because we’re sitting in front of the tube. It kind of allows us to still enjoy the good stuff that’s worth our precious time, and completely and utterly ignore the rest of the stuff out there.

    Example: I haven’t had to sit through a commercial in ages.

    I agree that television can be a fruitless waste of time, but Angela tells me that our broadband connection is the same. What we’ve attempted to do is limit our intake and make what we do watch worth the time spent.

    That being said, please give me just another 30 minutes, mister, please! I need it real bad!

  2. What I am about to say may sound kind of stupid and it may perhaps show my ignorance on this matter.

    If your problem is the wireless router connected to your Tivo, is there a wired connection solution? Could you connect the Tivo through a wired router to a desktop terminal and then use this machine to securely broadcast the Tivo signal wherever you wish it to go, wireless or not? You may need another network adapter on the desktop of course and some simple wiring since you may not be able to use those in your home.

    You should be able to find, I think, a great many wired routers old or new for very cheap or even free. Or will the wired router have the same driver support issues as the wireless router. All of this kind of sounds like Tivo needs to work out a solution.

    Please educate me.

  3. Travis, that would be ideal except for one thing. Our house, as you know has two floors. The second floor/first floor ceiling is off-limits from my drill bits according to Angela. Further, she has stated she is opposed to having CAT5 cabling running down the walls (we can’t go inside easily due to ancient fire blocking behind the plaster and/or brick exterior walls).

    I got the powerline ethernet blocks to work with ease last night. Setup took about 5 minutes, most of which was spent moving a bookshelf to find a free outlet. Who’d have thought that the solution to a most modern of problems was solved using wiring from 1938?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *